What’s the Difference Between a Marketing Agency, Consultant, and Fractional CMO? (And Which One Do You Need?)

If you’ve ever found yourself Googling terms like marketing agency vs. consultant or what is a fractional CMO, you’re not alone. As marketing options expand, so do the titles—and it can get confusing fast.

So let’s break it down. Whether you’re a small business owner, a startup founder, or a growing company trying to figure out your next marketing move, here’s a quick guide to understanding the differences between a full-service marketing agency, a marketing consultant, and a fractional CMO—and when you might need each.

Full-Service Marketing Agency: The One-Stop Shop

A full-service agency is typically made up of a team of specialists—graphic designers, copywriters, SEO pros, media buyers, and more—who offer a wide range of marketing services under one roof.

You’ll typically get:

• Branding and logo design

• Website development

• Paid ads (Google, Facebook, etc.)

• Social media management

• Email marketing and automation

• Creative campaigns and content production

  
  

Best for:

Companies that need hands-on help executing campaigns across multiple channels but don’t have the full in-house team to do so.

Marketing Consultant: The Strategy Guide

A marketing consultant (hey, that’s me!) is usually a senior-level marketer who works independently with companies to evaluate, strategize, and help solve marketing challenges.

You’ll typically get:

• Deep-dive audits of your current marketing

• Strategic planning and positioning

• Campaign direction and vendor coordination and management

• Clear messaging and brand voice development

• Honest, experienced advice—without fluff or jargon

• 
  

Best for:

Businesses that need clarity, a roadmap, or help figuring out what to do next—before spending a bunch of money on tactics that don’t work.

Fractional CMO: The Executive Without the Full-Time Salary

A fractional CMO (also me!) is a part-time or contract-based marketing executive who joins your leadership team to provide senior-level guidance and oversight.

You’ll typically get:

• Executive-level strategy and marketing leadership

• Management of your in-house team and/or vendors or agencies

• Growth planning, brand development, and budget oversight

• A partner to help you scale, pivot, or get unstuck

Best for:

Companies in growth mode or transition—maybe you're not ready (or can’t afford) a full-time CMO, but you need serious marketing leadership to drive results.

So… Which One Is Right for You?

Choose an agency if you need lots of hands executing multiple pieces of your marketing machine.

Choose a consultant if you want expert guidance, objective insight, and a flexible, strategic partner who can help you make smarter decisions.

Choose a fractional CMO if your business is growing and you need seasoned marketing leadership—but not full-time payroll costs.

Final Thought

The good news? You don’t have to choose blindly. I work with companies in a flexible way—sometimes as a consultant, sometimes as a fractional CMO, and sometimes helping manage their agency relationships. If you’re not sure what you need, let’s talk. I’ll help you figure it out—without the hard sell.

👉 Contact JP McGuirk Consulting to schedule a no-pressure conversation.